Tuesday, June 24, 2008

The Problem with Black-Themed Children's Books

I've discovered a serious problem as I'm searching to buy more. For the stage Sunny's at right now, they're either too negative or not exciting enough.

The ones about African-American history look exciting, but they bring up subjects I don't want to start discussing at this age. I'd rather wait at least a year or two.

The themes of the positive ones are... well... kind of crunchy, for lack of a better word. They would be great if he was already raised on that type of book and used to it. But he's not. He likes Dr. Seuss books, and then he likes things with trucks and spaceships and power rings and monsters and talking animals. It's difficult to get him to read anything else, and I certainly don't want to set up a dynamic where the only books he reads with black characters are the "boring" ones.

I've been doing internet searches and not coming up with a lot.

Here are three so far:
Bear on a Bike: this is below his level, but I think he'll really like the pictures.
I Need a Lunchbox: "A black girl is beginning first grade and getting all sorts of goodies, in particular a lunch box for which her little brother yearns with a single-minded passion. [...] At last, on his sister's first day of school, their father surprises the boy with a spaceship lunch box of his own." I think Sunny could really relate to the story.
Chinye: A West African Folk Tale: This story is very similar to Cinderella; it looks exciting and full of action.

What I'm really looking for is a rhyming picture book of a black truck driver with a talking animal sidekick whose truck can transform into a spaceship to fight monsters. As Sunny says, "that would be AWESOME good!"

7 comments:

Dawn said...

I know what you're saying here. I don't buy kids' books much because I get boxes of review books all the time and that's how I do my book shopping. Once you're on the list you stay on the list so I get catalogs every six months and then I just check off the ones I want to get. Pretty much any book with a non-white main character on the front cover gets checked off for me because I want picture books that just happen to feature not white kids. I don't even care if they're that good as long as they're not awful. So we have Marco's Run (about jogging -- it's a beginning reader) and Flower Garden by Eve Bunting (a very very pretty book) not because I think Madison will love them but because I'm just so happy to see them. I'll grab 'em just to outweigh the plethora of white characters sagging on our shelves.

dusobrown said...

Hi, I'm delurking with my $0.02. My 3 boys are now 11, 8 and 6 and some of their favorite books have been by Ezra Jack Keats. In particular I would suggest Goggles & Pet Show for a kid Sunny's age. Also, Shortcut and Big Mama by Donald Crews. There is some tension between the characters in those EJK books, and Shortcut induces some nervousness when the train comes. Nothing as exciting as a truck driver with a spaceship but a bit of drama to catch his attention.
You may want to try the Magic Schoolbus series. You may need to read them to him, but the bus turns into different things for each adventure, there is an iguana sidekick and the class is racially diverse. Also, Black Books Galore! has several guides to books with blakc characters. I think one of the guides is specifically for black boys. Good luck.
Julie

veggiegrrl said...

I really struggle with this in my classroom, too. Young Adult lit with non-white characters is hard to come by, unless it's dealing with a Big Issue or is historical fiction.

Maggie said...

Exactly. Books where the characters are black or any other race and the story isn't dependent on that.

Slugger is part Hispanic and is largely unaware of his culture. In fact, he once told me that "I can't be that, Mom, because my birth-mom didn't speak Spanish." Uhh...

I also struggle with finding books that meet Slugger's interest but are at a reading level that's appropriate for him. It's really difficult when your child's reading level is delayed, but their interests are right on target.

Christie D. said...

My kids bring home Scholastic book catalogues from school, and it has often annoyed me that the book with non-white characters are so limited...

Typically in the catalogue there will be a little section with 3 books, and they seem to hover around the same themes - one will be about a little slave girl, one will be about how black hair is beautiful too, etc... I would like to see (besides these books, which are probably nice books in themselves), a bigger variety, with different themes and stories, where the main character(s) just happen not to be white! Don't these publishers realize that such books would be welcomed by many people?

art-sweet said...

Delurking or redelurking ( I can't remember which) to say - have you seen this blog?

http://thebrownbookshelf.com/

I think you'll get a lot of ideas there!

Naomi Hirahara said...

A couple of multicultural publishers--Children's Book Press and Lee & Low--have some nice African American books. CBP has one called the TWO MRS. GIBSONS, which deals with a girl's Japanese and African American heritage. It may fall into that "boring" category for your son, but it may touch on some relevant issues.

Look at anything written or drawn by Kadir Nelson. He tends to do more historicals but his illustrations are amazing.